A Security Risk Assessment Guide for Medical Expert Witness Firms

Kevin Henry

Risk Management

Published Updated

7 minutes read
Share this article
A Security Risk Assessment Guide for Medical Expert Witness Firms

What electronic protected health information does your firm handle?

Start by identifying where electronic protected health information (ePHI) enters, moves through, and leaves your firm. For a medical expert witness practice, that may include medical records, imaging, case files, identifiable information in draft reports or testimony materials, email attachments, and data stored in document-management systems, cloud services, backups, or mobile devices.

Map each workflow: how records arrive from attorneys or other sources, who can access them, where they are stored, how they are shared, and what happens when a matter ends. Include paper-to-digital processes and third-party services if they create, receive, maintain, or transmit ePHI on your behalf. HHS guidance recommends identifying all ePHI and documenting how it is collected and handled; see HHS Guidance on Risk Analysis.

First determine whether HIPAA applies to your firm and the work in question. HIPAA’s Security Rule applies to covered entities and business associates, not automatically to every organization that handles medical records. A firm’s status depends on its role and relationship with the covered entity; review the relevant arrangements and contracts rather than assuming that the firm is—or is not—a business associate. See HHS guidance on covered entities and business associates.

How to assess administrative, physical, and technical safeguards

A HIPAA Security Rule risk analysis examines potential risks and vulnerabilities to the confidentiality, integrity, and availability of ePHI. Assess safeguards in context: what is appropriate depends on your firm’s size, complexity, capabilities, technology, and the probability and impact of risks. The Security Rule requires appropriate administrative, physical, and technical safeguards for regulated entities, as summarized in HHS’s overview of the Security Rule.

  • Administrative safeguards: Review who is responsible for security, how access is approved and removed, whether staff receive relevant training, how incidents are handled, and how vendors and contingency planning are managed.
  • Physical safeguards: Consider access to offices, work areas, devices, and storage media. Check whether screens and paper records are protected from visitors or unauthorized viewing, and how equipment is secured, moved, and disposed of.
  • Technical safeguards: Assess user access, authentication, audit logging, data integrity, and transmission security across the systems that handle ePHI. Review actual configurations and practices, not just written descriptions.

These examples help focus the review; they are not a substitute for evaluating the requirements that apply to your firm. HHS describes the safeguard categories in its Technical Safeguards guidance and Physical Safeguards guidance.

Which policies, systems, and personnel should the assessment cover?

Set a scope broad enough to include every system and workflow that creates, receives, maintains, or transmits ePHI. That may include case-management and document-sharing platforms, email, computers, phones, printers, scanners, removable media, remote-access tools, cloud storage, backups, and any systems used by outside service providers.

Review the policies and procedures that govern access, acceptable use, workforce security, incident response, backups and recovery, device handling, vendor relationships, and secure disposal. Compare documented procedures with what people actually do—for example, how a new expert or contractor receives case materials and how access is revoked when work ends.

Involve firm leadership, the person responsible for security, attorneys or case managers who handle records, experts, administrative staff, and relevant IT or service-provider personnel. Their input can reveal informal practices and overlooked data flows. HHS’s risk analysis guidance recommends gathering information through methods such as interviews, documentation reviews, and other data collection techniques.

How to document vulnerabilities and prioritize risks

For each system and workflow, record the threats that could affect ePHI, vulnerabilities that could be exploited, safeguards already in place, and any gaps. A vulnerability might include overly broad access, an unsupported device, an exposed file-sharing link, or a backup process that has not been tested. Identify the evidence behind each finding so you can distinguish verified weaknesses from unconfirmed concerns.

Estimate both the likelihood of a threat occurring and the potential impact on confidentiality, integrity, or availability. Use a consistent method to rank risks, then note the rationale, existing controls, and any uncertainties. HHS describes risk analysis as assessing potential risks and vulnerabilities and considering their likelihood and impact in its explanation of risk analysis and risk management.

Keep a written or electronic record of the assessment, including its scope, data inventory, findings, risk ratings, and decisions. For required Security Rule documentation, the regulation sets a six-year retention period from creation or the date the documentation was last in effect, whichever is later. See HHS guidance on documentation requirements.

Ready to assess your HIPAA security risks?

Join thousands of organizations that use Accountable to identify and fix their security gaps.

Take the Free Risk Assessment

How to develop and implement risk management measures

Turn the prioritized findings into a risk management plan. For each action, identify an owner, target date, resources needed, and how the firm will verify that the measure works. Possible measures include narrowing access to case files, improving account security, updating devices or software, revising procedures, or changing how records are sent and stored.

Choose measures based on your environment and the risks identified; a tool or policy alone does not show that the risk has been addressed. Test implementation where practical—for example, confirm that access has been removed when a matter closes or that a backup can be restored. HHS distinguishes risk analysis, which identifies and assesses risk, from risk management, which implements measures to reduce it. See HHS’s explanation of the difference.

When to revisit the assessment and update it

The HIPAA Security Rule requires periodic evaluation, but it does not set one universal interval—such as an annual assessment—for every organization. Set a review schedule that fits your firm’s operations and the sensitivity of its ePHI, and document the reasons for that schedule. Revisit the assessment sooner when a material change could affect security.

Triggers may include adopting a new case platform, changing cloud or IT providers, expanding remote work, changing how experts receive records, a security incident, or newly recognized threats. HHS explains that evaluations should be periodic and should respond to environmental or operational changes affecting ePHI in its Basics of Risk Analysis and Risk Management guidance.

What questionnaires can and cannot establish

Questionnaires can help gather information about policies, vendors, and staff practices, and they can highlight areas for follow-up. They cannot, by themselves, verify that safeguards are configured correctly, that every ePHI system has been identified, or that a stated procedure is consistently followed.

Use questionnaire answers as evidence to test, not as proof of security. Follow up with interviews, document and asset reviews, configuration checks, and appropriately scoped technical testing. HHS notes that a risk analysis must be accurate and thorough and that organizations should assess whether security measures are in place and properly configured; see HHS Guidance on Risk Analysis.

In summary, a useful assessment starts with a complete picture of ePHI and its workflows, evaluates safeguards and vulnerabilities, records and prioritizes risks, and tracks corrective measures. Reassess when operations or risks change, and use questionnaires as one input—not a substitute for verification.

FAQs.

Are medical expert witness firms required to conduct a HIPAA risk analysis?

It depends on whether the firm is a covered entity or business associate under HIPAA. Those regulated entities must conduct an accurate and thorough assessment of potential risks and vulnerabilities to ePHI. A firm is not automatically subject to the Security Rule simply because it handles medical records; its role and relationship to covered entities matter. See HHS guidance on covered entities and business associates and HHS Guidance on Risk Analysis.

What systems and workflows should an ePHI risk assessment include?

Include the systems and workflows that create, receive, maintain, or transmit ePHI. For an expert witness firm, that may include record intake, case-management tools, email, file sharing, devices, remote access, printing and scanning, backups, vendor services, and secure disposal. Trace the information through the people and systems involved, including how access begins and ends.

How often should a medical expert witness firm revisit its security risk assessment?

The Security Rule requires periodic evaluation but does not prescribe one fixed review interval for all organizations. Establish and document a schedule suited to your firm’s environment, and reassess when changes or incidents may affect ePHI security—for example, new technology, changed workflows, or newly recognized risks.

Are security questionnaires enough to identify technical vulnerabilities?

No. Questionnaires can collect useful information, but they do not independently establish that technical safeguards are present, correctly configured, or effective. Verify responses through interviews, system and configuration reviews, and appropriately scoped technical testing.

Share this article

Ready to assess your HIPAA security risks?

Join thousands of organizations that use Accountable to identify and fix their security gaps.

Take the Free Risk Assessment

Related Articles