New York Breach Notification Law for Health Data: What You Need to Know
New York’s breach notification rules can apply to health data held by providers, insurers, businesses, and service providers. The key question is whether an incident exposed the specific kind of identifiable “private information” covered by state law—not simply whether the data is sensitive.
Which New York laws govern health data breach notifications?
The main notification law is New York General Business Law Section 899-aa, part of the New York SHIELD Act. It requires notice when a qualifying security breach involves a New York resident’s private information. The related Section 899-bb requires reasonable safeguards for computerized private information and describes administrative, technical, and physical security measures.
New York Public Health Law Section 18 governs access to certain patient information held by health care providers; it is not the state’s general breach-notification statute. Health care organizations may also have federal obligations under HIPAA. The HHS HIPAA Breach Notification Rule applies to covered entities and business associates when a breach involves unsecured protected health information (PHI).
What health data and personal information are covered?
Under Section 899-aa, “private information” generally means identifying personal information combined with one or more specified data elements, when the element or combination is unencrypted—or encrypted with an encryption key that was also accessed or acquired. Covered elements include medical information, health insurance information, and certain biometric information, as well as Social Security numbers, driver’s license numbers, and specified financial-account information.
Medical information includes information about an individual’s medical history, mental or physical condition, or treatment or diagnosis by a health care professional. Health insurance information includes policy or subscriber identification numbers, other unique identifiers used by a health insurer, and information in an individual’s application or claims history. Biometric information is covered when it is generated from measurements of unique physical characteristics and used to authenticate or ascertain identity. The statute excludes certain information lawfully available to the public from government records. Section 899-aa’s definitions specify these categories.
Genetic information is not separately named in Section 899-aa’s list of private-information elements. Depending on what it reveals and how it is linked to an identifiable person, it may qualify as medical information; assess the particular data and any other applicable privacy requirements rather than assuming every genetic record is automatically covered by this definition.
What events trigger a notification requirement?
A breach occurs when unauthorized access to or acquisition of computerized data compromises the security, confidentiality, or integrity of private information maintained by a business. The statute covers access as well as acquisition, so an organization should not assume notice is unnecessary merely because it has not confirmed that data was copied or misused. In assessing whether access or acquisition occurred or is reasonably believed to have occurred, the business may consider signs that the information was viewed, communicated with, used, altered, downloaded, or copied.
Good-faith access to or acquisition of information by an employee or agent for business purposes is not a breach if the information is not used or subject to unauthorized disclosure. The law also provides a limited exception for certain inadvertent disclosures by authorized people; the organization must document its assessment and follow the conditions described below. See the current statutory definition of a breach.
Ready to simplify HIPAA compliance?
Join thousands of organizations that trust Accountable to manage their compliance needs.
Get Started Free TodayWhat are the deadlines and notice requirements?
When notice is required, the business must notify affected New York residents as quickly as possible and without unreasonable delay, but no later than 30 days after discovering the breach. A law-enforcement agency may require a delay if notice would impede a criminal investigation; notice must then be provided once the agency determines it will no longer compromise the investigation. A business maintaining computerized private information it does not own must notify the owner or licensee immediately, and within 30 days after discovery.
Notice to individuals must include contact information for the notifying business, contact information for relevant state and federal agencies that provide breach-response or identity-theft information, and a description of the information accessed or acquired—or reasonably believed to have been accessed or acquired. Permitted methods include written notice, electronic notice with the recipient’s express consent, or telephone notice. Substitute notice is available only under specified conditions, such as insufficient contact information, a notification class exceeding 500,000 people, or direct-notice costs exceeding $250,000; the required substitute notice includes email when available, website posting when applicable, and notice to major statewide media. See Section 899-aa’s timing and notice rules.
HIPAA has its own deadlines for breaches of unsecured PHI, including a general limit of 60 days for individual notice. That does not replace New York’s 30-day deadline when the New York law applies. Organizations subject to both should assess and meet each applicable requirement. HHS explains HIPAA’s separate notification requirements.
Who must be notified after a breach?
If New York residents are to receive notice, the business must also notify the New York State Attorney General, the Department of State, and the Division of State Police about the timing, content, and distribution of the notice and the approximate number of affected people. A copy of the notice template must be provided. The New York Attorney General’s SHIELD Act guidance explains that submitting the breach form through its reporting portal is sufficient to provide the required notice to the Attorney General, Department of State, and State Police.
Notice to the New York Department of Financial Services is also required when the business is a covered entity under the applicable state financial-services regulation. If more than 5,000 New York residents are to be notified at one time, the business must also notify consumer reporting agencies; these notices must not delay notice to affected residents. A HIPAA-covered entity that must notify the HHS Secretary of a breach must notify the New York Attorney General within five business days after notifying the Secretary, including when the breach involves information that is not “private information” under Section 899-aa.
For a HIPAA-regulated breach, the organization may also need to notify HHS and, when more than 500 residents of a state or jurisdiction are affected, prominent media outlets serving that area. Business associates must notify the covered entity when a breach occurs at or by the business associate. See HHS’s HIPAA notification guidance and Section 899-aa’s state-notification provisions.
What exceptions and safeguards may apply?
New York does not require notice to affected individuals for a qualifying inadvertent disclosure by someone authorized to access the information if the business reasonably determines the exposure is unlikely to result in misuse or financial harm—or, for exposed online credentials, emotional harm. The business must document the determination in writing and keep it for at least five years. If more than 500 New York residents are affected, it must provide that written determination to the Attorney General within 10 days after making it. Other reporting obligations may still apply.
Encryption matters when determining whether the exposed information meets Section 899-aa’s definition of private information: the statutory definition includes data encrypted with a key that was also accessed or acquired. HIPAA has a separate encryption safe harbor for PHI secured using technologies and methodologies specified by HHS, provided the confidential process or key has not been breached. Encryption therefore requires a facts-based review; confirm what was encrypted, how it was encrypted, and whether the key was compromised. See Section 899-aa and HHS’s encryption guidance.
Section 899-bb also requires reasonable safeguards for computerized private information, such as risk assessment, staff training, service-provider controls, technical monitoring, and appropriate physical protections. Organizations already subject to certain specified federal or state data-security rules may be deemed compliant with that safeguard requirement if they meet those rules. These safeguards do not eliminate the need to assess and report a breach when notification rules apply. See General Business Law Section 899-bb.
FAQs.
Does New York require notice when health data is exposed?
It can. Notice is generally required when unauthorized access to or acquisition of computerized data compromises a New York resident’s private information as defined by Section 899-aa. Not every exposure of health-related information automatically triggers this law; the organization must assess the information involved, whether it identifies an individual, whether it was accessed or acquired without authorization, and whether an exception applies. New York General Business Law Section 899-aa sets out the trigger and exceptions.
What types of health information are covered by New York breach notification law?
The statute includes medical information about a person’s medical history, mental or physical condition, or professional treatment or diagnosis, as well as specified health insurance information. It also covers qualifying biometric information used to authenticate or ascertain identity. These elements must meet the law’s definition of private information, including its rules about identifying information and encryption. Genetic information is not separately listed, though particular genetic data may qualify as medical information depending on its content and context.
How soon must a New York health data breach be reported?
When New York resident notice is required, it must be made as quickly as possible, without unreasonable delay, and within 30 days after discovery, subject to a law-enforcement delay. Separate reporting duties may apply to state agencies, the HHS Secretary, media, or other recipients, depending on the organization and incident. Section 899-aa and the HHS HIPAA guidance describe the respective requirements.
Does encryption affect New York breach notification obligations?
Yes. Under New York’s definition, an otherwise covered data element encrypted with an encryption key that was also accessed or acquired can still qualify as private information. HIPAA separately provides a safe harbor for PHI encrypted in accordance with HHS guidance when the key has not been breached. The practical takeaway is to assess New York and HIPAA triggers separately, document what happened to the data and encryption keys, and meet every applicable deadline.
Table of Contents
Ready to simplify HIPAA compliance?
Join thousands of organizations that trust Accountable to manage their compliance needs.
Get Started Free Today