HIPAA-Compliant EHR Research Recruitment Policy Template for Community Hospitals
This template sets out a hospital process for reviewing electronic health record (EHR) information to identify potential research participants and contacting them while protecting protected health information (PHI). The hospital’s Privacy Officer, research leadership, and legal counsel should adapt it to the hospital’s operations, applicable state law, and any research rules that apply.
What does HIPAA allow for preparatory-to-research EHR access?
Under HIPAA’s preparatory-to-research provision, a covered hospital may permit a researcher to use or review PHI for activities such as developing a research protocol or identifying potentially eligible patients, without first obtaining each patient’s HIPAA authorization or an IRB or Privacy Board waiver. The researcher must make the required representations that the PHI is sought solely for a preparatory purpose, is necessary for the research, and will not be removed from the covered entity by the researcher. See 45 CFR § 164.512(i)(1)(ii) and the HHS preparatory-to-research recruitment guidance.
Policy template: Before EHR review begins, the researcher must provide the hospital with a written preparatory-to-research representation describing the purpose and scope of access. The hospital’s designated research or privacy official must confirm that the request fits this pathway, approve the access, and document the approval. Access must be limited to information reasonably needed to assess feasibility, prepare the protocol, or identify potential participants.
Preparatory-to-research access is not general permission to build an unrestricted recruitment list or take PHI away from the hospital. Hospital policy should specify where the review may occur, what information may be viewed, who may view it, and when access ends. HHS explains that the provision may support recruitment but does not allow the researcher to remove PHI from the covered entity’s site. HHS guidance on preparatory-to-research recruitment.
How can hospital workforce researchers contact potential participants?
A researcher who is a member of the hospital’s workforce may use preparatory-to-research access to identify prospective participants and contact them to seek authorization for the study. HHS also states that covered health care providers and patients may discuss the option of joining a clinical trial without prior authorization or an IRB or Privacy Board waiver. The contact must remain within the approved recruitment purpose and the hospital’s policies. HHS recruitment guidance.
Policy template: Only workforce members approved for the study may conduct recruitment. They must use hospital-approved contact information and scripts, follow the patient’s communication preferences where known, and avoid sharing a patient’s identity or health information with people who are not authorized to receive it. When a patient expresses interest, the researcher must follow the approved process for explaining the study and obtaining any required HIPAA authorization and informed consent before using or disclosing PHI for the research.
HIPAA authorization and informed consent serve different purposes. Authorization permits specified uses or disclosures of PHI under the Privacy Rule; informed consent addresses a person’s voluntary participation in research when required by applicable human-subjects rules. One document may combine them if it meets the applicable requirements. HHS HIPAA and Research guidance.
What rules apply to recruitment by outside researchers?
An outside researcher who is not part of the hospital’s workforce may not use the preparatory-to-research provision to contact prospective participants directly. If PHI must be disclosed to an outside researcher so that the researcher can identify or contact potential participants, the hospital generally needs a valid HIPAA authorization or documentation of a partial IRB waiver of authorization or Privacy Board waiver covering that recruitment activity. HHS guidance on outside researchers and recruitment.
Policy template: An outside researcher must not access or receive identifiable recruitment information until the hospital’s Privacy Officer or designee verifies the applicable authorization or waiver documentation and approves the requested disclosure. The approval must define the information that may be disclosed, the recruitment purpose, the permitted recipients, and any limits on retention or further use. The hospital may require additional contractual, security, or institutional review before access is granted.
Where the hospital discloses PHI for a research purpose, it should assess the request under the applicable Privacy Rule requirements and its own policies. The minimum necessary standard generally applies to PHI uses and disclosures, but it does not apply to uses or disclosures made pursuant to a valid individual authorization. HHS minimum necessary guidance.
Ready to simplify HIPAA compliance?
Join thousands of organizations that trust Accountable to manage their compliance needs.
Get Started Free TodayWhen is individual authorization or an IRB or Privacy Board waiver required?
Before a hospital uses or discloses PHI for research, it must have a permitted basis under the Privacy Rule. Common pathways include a valid HIPAA authorization, an applicable waiver or alteration of authorization approved by an IRB or Privacy Board, or a specific regulatory exception such as preparatory-to-research access. A preparatory-to-research representation permits only the activities covered by that provision; it does not by itself authorize an outside researcher to contact patients. HHS HIPAA and Research guidance and 45 CFR § 164.512.
An IRB waiver of authorization or Privacy Board waiver may be full or partial. For example, a board may waive authorization only for the limited disclosure of contact information needed to invite potential participants, while requiring authorization before other PHI is used or disclosed for the study. The Privacy Rule requires the board to determine that the use or disclosure involves no more than minimal risk to privacy, that the research could not practicably be conducted without the waiver or alteration, and that it could not practicably be conducted without access to or use of PHI.
The waiver documentation must identify the IRB or Privacy Board and approval date; state that the board found the required criteria satisfied; briefly describe the PHI needed; state whether review was normal or expedited; and include the signature of the chair or designated member. The hospital must obtain and retain this documentation before relying on the waiver. HHS waiver requirements and documentation guidance.
Policy template: The study file must include the authorization or applicable regulatory documentation before the hospital makes a research-related disclosure of PHI. The Privacy Officer or designee must review the scope and expiration or other limits of the document and ensure that the proposed access or disclosure stays within them. Other research approvals, including informed-consent or IRB requirements, may apply separately.
What safeguards should govern EHR-based recruitment information?
The hospital must apply appropriate safeguards to PHI and limit access to authorized people and purposes. For electronic PHI, the Security Rule requires administrative, physical, and technical safeguards, including access controls, audit controls, and person or entity authentication. HHS Summary of the HIPAA Security Rule.
Policy template: For each approved recruitment activity, the hospital should:
- Assign access only to named, authorized workforce members or approved outside recipients, and limit access to the records and fields needed for the approved purpose.
- Use role-based, time-limited EHR permissions where available; prohibit shared credentials and unauthorized copying, downloading, printing, photographing, or exporting of recruitment information.
- Keep an auditable record of approvals, access, disclosures, and any recruitment list created for the study.
- Store approved recruitment information only in hospital-authorized systems with appropriate access restrictions, and dispose of or return it under the approved retention and destruction process.
- Require prompt reporting of suspected improper access, use, loss, or disclosure through the hospital’s incident-reporting process.
These operational controls are policy recommendations for implementing protected health information safeguards; HIPAA does not prescribe every specific control in this list for every hospital. The hospital should select and document reasonable and appropriate safeguards in light of its systems, risks, and applicable requirements. The minimum necessary standard applies where required by the Privacy Rule, subject to its exceptions. HHS minimum necessary guidance.
How should recruitment communications protect PHI?
Recruitment communications should disclose only what is needed to invite the person to learn about the study. Use hospital-approved scripts and channels, verify the recipient before discussing study or health details, and avoid putting a diagnosis, treatment detail, or other unnecessary PHI in voicemail, text-message previews, email subject lines, or messages that may be seen by others. Follow the hospital’s approved procedures for documenting communication preferences and requests not to be contacted.
When electronic communications contain ePHI, the hospital must protect it against unauthorized access during transmission. HIPAA’s Security Rule makes encryption an addressable implementation specification: the hospital must assess whether it is reasonable and appropriate, implement it when it is, or document its decision and use an appropriate alternative where applicable. Therefore, use hospital-approved encrypted recruitment communications when required by the risk assessment and hospital policy; do not assume that every communication must use a particular encryption method. HHS encryption guidance and HHS guidance on email and ePHI.
Policy template: Staff must use approved communication systems for any recruitment message containing ePHI, confirm recipients and addresses before sending, and follow hospital procedures for secure messaging, encryption, and misdirected communications. Where possible, the initial invitation should be neutral and direct the patient to a secure method for receiving study details.
In summary, this policy should distinguish preparatory-to-research access from research use or disclosure, limit workforce and outside-researcher access to an approved pathway, document authorization or waiver requirements, and protect recruitment information through appropriate access and communication safeguards.
FAQs.
Can a hospital researcher review EHR records to assess study feasibility?
Yes, if the review qualifies as an activity preparatory to research and the researcher provides the required representations: the PHI is sought solely for a preparatory purpose, is necessary for the research, and will not be removed from the covered entity by the researcher. The hospital should approve and limit the access under its policy. 45 CFR § 164.512(i)(1)(ii).
Can a workforce researcher contact patients without prior authorization?
A hospital workforce researcher may use preparatory-to-research access to identify and contact prospective participants to seek their authorization. A covered provider and patient may also discuss the option of enrolling in a clinical trial without prior authorization or a waiver. Further use or disclosure of PHI for the research must have an applicable HIPAA basis. HHS recruitment guidance.
Can an outside researcher contact patients using preparatory-to-research access?
No. HHS states that an outside researcher may not use the preparatory-to-research provision to contact prospective participants. The hospital generally needs a valid authorization or a partial IRB or Privacy Board waiver permitting the relevant disclosure of PHI for recruitment. HHS guidance on outside researchers.
What must an IRB or Privacy Board waiver include?
The board must make the required findings about minimal privacy risk and the impracticability of conducting the research without the waiver or without PHI. The hospital must obtain documentation identifying the board and approval date, recording the findings, describing the PHI needed, stating the review procedure, and bearing the required chair or designated member’s signature. HHS waiver criteria and documentation guidance.
Table of Contents
- What does HIPAA allow for preparatory-to-research EHR access?
- How can hospital workforce researchers contact potential participants?
- What rules apply to recruitment by outside researchers?
- When is individual authorization or an IRB or Privacy Board waiver required?
- What safeguards should govern EHR-based recruitment information?
- How should recruitment communications protect PHI?
- FAQs.
Ready to simplify HIPAA compliance?
Join thousands of organizations that trust Accountable to manage their compliance needs.
Get Started Free Today