New York SHIELD Act: Healthcare Data Breach Requirements

Kevin Henry

Data Breaches

Published Updated

9 minutes read
Share this article
New York SHIELD Act: Healthcare Data Breach Requirements

What healthcare information is covered by the New York SHIELD Act?

The New York SHIELD Act covers certain private information in computerized data. That can include medical information—such as a person’s medical history, physical or mental condition, or treatment or diagnosis by a healthcare professional—and health insurance information, such as a policy or subscriber ID, an insurer’s unique identifier, or application and claims history. New York General Business Law § 899-aa defines these categories as private information when they are combined with personal information that can identify the individual, and the information is not encrypted or the encryption key has also been accessed or acquired.

Other covered data elements include Social Security numbers, certain driver’s license numbers, financial account information, biometric information, and credentials that could provide access to an online account. The law’s definition concerns computerized private information; not every medical record automatically meets that definition. HIPAA protected health information (PHI) and SHIELD Act private information overlap, but they are not identical categories.

When does a healthcare data incident qualify as a breach?

Under the SHIELD Act, a breach occurs when an unauthorized person—or someone acting without valid authorization—accesses or acquires computerized data in a way that compromises the security, confidentiality, or integrity of private information. A business may consider evidence such as information being viewed, communicated, used, altered, downloaded, copied, or held on a lost or stolen device. The statute’s breach definition and examples distinguish unauthorized access or acquisition from a mere incident that does not compromise private information.

Good-faith access or acquisition by an employee or agent for business purposes is not a SHIELD Act breach if the information is not used or subjected to unauthorized disclosure. For HIPAA, an impermissible use or disclosure of PHI is generally presumed to be a breach unless an exception applies or a documented assessment shows a low probability that the PHI was compromised. See HHS guidance on the HIPAA Breach Notification Rule.

How does HIPAA compliance affect SHIELD Act security safeguards?

Healthcare organizations that are subject to HIPAA and comply with its applicable data-security requirements are treated as compliant with the SHIELD Act’s reasonable-safeguards requirement. This is a limited safeguards provision: it does not make HIPAA compliance a blanket exemption from New York breach reporting. The statutory definition requires both that an entity be subject to the relevant rules and that it be in compliance. See New York General Business Law § 899-bb.

For breach notices to affected people, New York law says that when notice is provided under HIPAA’s breach-notification requirements, a second notice to those people under SHIELD is not required. New York agencies must still receive the applicable notice. HIPAA’s individual-notice deadline is generally no later than 60 calendar days after discovery, while SHIELD’s ordinary resident-notice deadline is 30 days; determine which reporting pathway applies rather than assuming HIPAA compliance eliminates every New York obligation. Section 899-aa sets out the interaction between the laws, and HHS explains HIPAA notification requirements.

Who must healthcare entities notify after a breach?

Under SHIELD, a business that owns or licenses computerized data must notify affected New York residents when their private information was, or is reasonably believed to have been, accessed or acquired without authorization. If the business maintains the data but does not own it, it must notify the owner or licensee. New York’s statute also requires notice to the New York Attorney General, Department of State, and Division of State Police when residents are to be notified. Notice to the Department of Financial Services is also required when the business is a covered entity under the applicable DFS regulation.

For more than 5,000 New York residents being notified at one time, the business must also notify consumer reporting agencies. A HIPAA-covered entity that must notify the HHS Secretary about a breach must notify the New York Attorney General within five business days of notifying the Secretary—even if the breached information does not meet SHIELD’s definition of private information. Section 899-aa specifies these additional reporting duties.

HIPAA separately requires covered entities to notify affected individuals and HHS after a breach of unsecured PHI; notice to prominent media outlets is required when more than 500 residents of a state or jurisdiction are affected. Business associates must notify the covered entity. See HHS’s HIPAA breach-notification guidance.

Ready to simplify HIPAA compliance?

Join thousands of organizations that trust Accountable to manage their compliance needs.

Get Started Free Today

What is the deadline for notifying affected New York residents?

Under the ordinary SHIELD Act rule, resident notice must be provided as soon as practicable and without unreasonable delay, and no later than 30 days after discovery of the breach. Law enforcement may delay notice when an agency determines that disclosure would impede a criminal investigation; notice must then be made after the agency determines it will no longer compromise the investigation. Section 899-aa states the deadline and law-enforcement exception.

When the organization provides affected-person notice under HIPAA’s breach-notification requirements, SHIELD does not require a duplicate notice to those people. HIPAA requires individual notice without unreasonable delay and no later than 60 calendar days after discovery. The HIPAA deadline does not replace New York’s separate regulator-notification obligations. See HHS’s HIPAA guidance and New York General Business Law § 899-aa.

New York notices must describe the categories of information accessed or acquired and provide contact information for the notifying organization and relevant agencies. The law allows written, electronic, telephone, or—when statutory conditions are met—substitute notice. The statute specifies the notice content and permitted delivery methods.

When can an inadvertent disclosure qualify for a notification exception?

SHIELD does not require notice to affected people when an authorized person inadvertently discloses private information and the organization reasonably determines the exposure is unlikely to result in misuse or financial harm. For unknown disclosure of online credentials, the assessment also considers potential emotional harm. The organization must document its determination in writing and keep it for at least five years. If more than 500 New York residents are affected, it must provide that written determination to the Attorney General within 10 days after making it. New York General Business Law § 899-aa sets out these conditions.

HIPAA has separate exceptions, including certain good-faith, in-scope workforce uses that do not result in further impermissible use or disclosure, and certain inadvertent disclosures between people authorized to access PHI. Where no exception applies, a HIPAA-regulated organization may still avoid notification if its documented risk assessment establishes a low probability that the PHI was compromised. These HIPAA tests are distinct from the SHIELD Act exception. See HHS’s explanation of HIPAA breach exceptions and documentation.

What administrative, technical, and physical safeguards are required?

Organizations that own or license computerized data containing a New York resident’s private information must develop, implement, and maintain reasonable safeguards to protect its security, confidentiality, and integrity, including appropriate disposal. The law lists examples rather than a one-size-fits-all checklist. See New York General Business Law § 899-bb.

  • Administrative safeguards: Designate a person or people to coordinate the security program; identify foreseeable internal and external risks; assess whether safeguards address those risks; train and manage employees; choose capable service providers and require appropriate safeguards by contract; and update the program as circumstances change.
  • Technical safeguards: Assess risks in network and software design and in information processing, transmission, and storage; detect, prevent, and respond to attacks or system failures; and regularly test and monitor key controls, systems, and procedures.
  • Physical safeguards: Assess storage and disposal risks; detect, prevent, and respond to intrusions; protect private information during and after collection, transport, and disposal; and securely erase electronic media when information is no longer needed for business purposes.

HIPAA’s Security Rule also requires administrative, physical, and technical safeguards for electronic PHI for covered entities and business associates. Organizations should assess their specific obligations under both regimes; being subject to HIPAA alone is not the same as demonstrating that the organization is actually in compliance. See the SHIELD Act’s compliant-regulated-entity provision and HHS’s HIPAA guidance.

In short, assess whether the data meets New York’s definition of private information, determine which breach-notification pathway applies, meet the relevant deadlines, and document both reporting decisions and safeguards.

FAQs.

Does the SHIELD Act cover medical and health insurance information?

Yes. The statute includes medical information and health insurance information in its definition of private information when the information is combined with personal information that identifies an individual and the data is not encrypted, or the encryption key has also been accessed or acquired. See New York General Business Law § 899-aa.

Must HIPAA-compliant entities also meet SHIELD Act safeguards?

An entity subject to and compliant with HIPAA’s applicable data-security requirements is treated as compliant with the SHIELD Act’s safeguards requirement. That provision concerns safeguards; HIPAA compliance does not automatically remove separate New York agency-notification duties. New York General Business Law § 899-bb and § 899-aa describe these provisions.

How soon must affected New York residents be notified?

Ordinarily, within the most expedient time possible and without unreasonable delay, but no later than 30 days after discovery under SHIELD. When resident notice is provided under HIPAA’s breach-notification requirements, New York law does not require a duplicate notice; HIPAA generally sets a 60-day outside limit. New York General Business Law § 899-aa and HHS’s HIPAA guidance explain the respective rules.

Which New York authorities must receive breach notice?

When New York residents are to be notified, the Attorney General, Department of State, and Division of State Police must receive notice. The Department of Financial Services must also be notified when the business is a covered entity under the applicable DFS regulation. A HIPAA-covered entity required to notify the HHS Secretary must notify the New York Attorney General within five business days after notifying the Secretary. New York General Business Law § 899-aa.

Share this article

Ready to simplify HIPAA compliance?

Join thousands of organizations that trust Accountable to manage their compliance needs.

Get Started Free Today

Related Articles